The list of books which have been nominated more than once:
Winners
| Title | Noms | History |
| The Stars My Destination | 3 | May 2004 (DKB), Dec 2007 (DKB), July 2008 (DKB) |
| Blink | 2 | April 2006 (DKB), Nov 2006 (Kay) |
| Death and the Penguin | 2 | June 2006 (EmmaJ), May 2008 (John) |
| Mrs Dalloway | 2 | Feb 2005 (John), April 2010 (Anthony) |
| Strangers on a Train | 2 | Feb 2010 (Catherine), Dec 2010 (DKB) |
| The Beautiful and Damned | 2 | Jan 2012 (John), Dec 2012 (DKB) |
| The Black Dahlia | 2 | March 2004 (EmmaJ), Sept 2009 (DKB) |
| The Talented Mr. Ripley | 2 | Sept 2005 (EmmaJ), Nov 2012 (Catherine) |
| The White Tiger | 2 | June 2010 (Baljit), Nov 2011 (Baljit) |
| What a Carve Up! | 2 | Sept 2005 (EmmaJ), Nov 2007 (EmmaJ) |
Losers
Books which haven’t quite made the cut (yet):
| Title | Noms | History |
| Of Love and Hunger | 2 | July 2007 (Anthony), Oct 2007 (John) |
| Of Mice and Men | 2 | March 2009 (John), April 2011 (John) |
| Raisin in the Sun | 2 | Dec 2008 (DKB), July 2011 (DKB) |
| Reading Lolita in Tehran: A Memoir in Books | 2 | May 2005 (EmmaT), July 2012 (EmmaT) |
| The Cellist of Sarajevo | 2 | Nov 2010 (EmmaJ), Dec 2010 (DKB) |
| The House of Mirth | 2 | Oct 2012 (Baljit), Dec 2012 (DKB) |
| The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner | 2 | June 2004 (John), Nov 2006 (Kay) |
| The Moon and Sixpence | 2 | April 2010 (Anthony), May 2011 (Anthony) |
| The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie | 2 | Sept 2006 (EmmaT), June 2008 (Catherine) |
| The Rachel Papers | 2 | Jan 2010 (John), Dec 2010 (DKB) |
| The Woman in White | 2 | June 2012 (DKB), Dec 2012 (DKB) |
| To Kill a Mockingbird | 2 | Nov 2006 (Kay), Nov 2007 (EmmaJ) |
| Wide Sargasso Sea | 2 | Sept 2006 (EmmaT), Jan 2013 (Miranda) |
Produced July 2012